Who would win?

What kind of hive are we talking here? How many? Does it have Praetorians? Landscap matters too. If the hive were the size as the one in Aliens, then the Predators might win in an open field, or somewhere with a choke point, but they'd be done in seconds if they were in a complex cave system.

Sorry for not including that. 1. A big hive. About 15-20 Warriors, maybe about 5 or 6 Drones. The Praetorian is a secret. ;) 2. It's a pretty big hive. Probably like in AVP.

To be completely honest it would depend. Something like this is actually almost impossible to actually guess for. Even if we had conclusive evidence of how they would react, it would never be the same for every time it happened, a Predator may trip and die during one run while it might not the next. (All assuming of course that we found the average out of per say 100 tests). To be honest it would be close, however the Berserk had a pretty difficult time taking on a weakened Predator. Had the Predator had fully operational equipment such as the Super did, he would have probably made for an even fight anyways. So to be honest, depending on strategy, tech, alertness, etc. It would be a very close if not almost unimaginable battle. However if it were in the AvP Hive as you say, and the Supers had access to the pyramid scheme, I would assume it would be an even playing field for both sides, if they didn't, the Xeno's would have a much higher advantage over them. Regardless I feel like a Praetorian alone could quite literally take at least one down alone, maybe even two. The rest is just a matter of assumptions and mathematics really. However I feel like with a Queen the battle wouldn't last much longer than the AvP one, especially acknowledging the fact that there would be no chain and advantage of a heavy ass silo to drag it into the ocean.

Alright, to answer all other questions: The queen is in an enclosed area in the hive, which IS AN YAJUTA HUNTING GROUND (an abandoned hunting ground infested with Xenomorphs) The hive is in a temple, and the queen is in a large, square room with a few colomns holding up the ceiling. Our evidence? Funny you asked, it's an AVP-like temple, and only one of one race will make it out alive. To have you all know, I am thinking heavily about this. I'm reading and hearing about other fights. I'm going to ask some of my friends at school, who also know a lot in this subject, who they think would win. Just to let you know, this is a simple preview. I'm posting this on a new discussion page for the accual battle. It's going to be a long, action-packed story that will have readers begging for a sequel. It has less aliens than the AVP one, in total some 26 Xenomorphs vs. 3 Super Predators. There's NOT going to be some super edvanced alien like Grid that kills two of the predators halfway through the battle. Also, remember to put an entry in my create-a-Xenomorph competition!

Coolio~! Can't wait to see it!

Im with the sci fi king on this one grid was ENOURMUSLY OP he killed the celtic easily grid was a mistake but now if there was a predator in this like scar........... just plain on simple words here: aliens would get their asses kicked so friggen bad

3 super predators got killed by a group of 9 humans. It's closer to 7 really though since one guy is killed by their dogs, and another is a doctor who is more focused on killing people and never actually tries to fight them. 

Aliens would tear them apart, especially in an enclosed place like a temple that offers a lot of areas for the alien to collapse on them. Assuming the queen gets loose she would kill at least 2 by herself, and any praetorian could probably take the other.